Last modified on Thu 1 Feb 2018
Pointless competition and illusory ‘choice’ have choked our streets and literally undermined our cities
The second month of the year begins with London having already reached its legal air pollution limit for the whole of 2018. The city’s limit of 18 breaches of air quality regulations was used up in January.
Mostly invisible, this silent killer causes an estimated 40,000 early deaths a year in Britain. That’s about 25 times more than roads deaths. Imagine if there were that many murders or NHS accidents or flu epidemic deaths.
The capital may be worst, but around the country filthy air pollutes the lungs in many cities. Check this pollution map to see what you are breathing. Though don’t imagine we necessarily know the worst of it. In research for our book Dismembered, David Walker and I found environmental officers, cut by a third, were closing as many as two-thirds of air quality monitoring stations, for lack of staff to check them.
As with most of the gravest problems facing Britain, the solutions are relatively easy to find: the problem, as ever, in this fractured and fractious country, is summoning up the collective political will to take action. It turns out privatisation of national utilities is a significant cause of air pollution in a number of ways.
Take the explosion of van deliveries as the Amazon I–want-it-now impulse is followed by every company that wants to stay in business. Be it Argos or John Lewis, everyone delivers it to your doorstep fast, multiple vans criss-crossing each other and knocking on the same doors over and over. Van traffic has grown faster than any other vehicle type since 2005.
Why? Royal Mail visits every household once a day, these days delivering mostly junk mail at ever-rising stamp prices for lack of volume business. As predicted, private companies cherrypick easy deliveries, leaving Royal Mail to take single letters to every remote farm.
If Labour is going to renationalise it, the party should consider giving Royal Mail back its delivery monopoly, either by law or by incentive, with punitive levies on needless extra deliveries, making the last mile to front doors a presumed Royal Mail function for most parcels.
Consolidating collection points for parcels at railway stations needs an extra boost: the one at Victoria has a changing room so you can send back unwanted clothes there and then. But escalating door-to-door delivery is yet another example of the destructiveness of bringing competition into a national utility. That was done in the name of choice, price-cutting, investment and efficiency – but wrecking Royal Mail has helped cause traffic congestion and air pollution that no one chose.
Look how bringing pointless competition to utilities has caused an explosion of roadworks with all its extra trucks, as competing companies dig up miles of roads and slow the traffic, which idles at blockages. Although better public transport, congestion charging and congestion itself have cut car-use dramatically in London, traffic speeds are falling – down to 7.5mph in the mornings and predicted to reach walking speed soon unless there is change.
Steep road pricing would force more consolidation of journeys and deliveries.